R-18
I've spoken a few times with some of my darlings on my definitions of certain genres, and how they sit in my head. Most recently, I spoke with Moonflower on why I hold First Aid Kit to be Americana, and how I understand that genre. I don't perceive genres to be an aesthetic; they are not a box to fit into, but a frame into which an artist places their work, a lens through which to see it. Of course, this understanding of genre is completely subjective.
I could never be a proper critic; I care more about understanding the work as I experienced it than how the work might fit into a petri dish for analysis. And this, of course, isn't to suggest that my way of exploring works is a better way! There is importance in criticism; we need people who are well-studied in the art we create to tell us what they experienced! This feedback, as all feedback, is vital! I explore like this because I believe all art matters, all art has merit – and I revel in the finding of that merit, rejoice in diving into a work and returning to the surface with what I found therein; I love to share my findings!
At my father's feet do I lay the responsibility of priming my mind to determine the genre of music by its lyrical composition, and how it intertwines with the instrumentals accompanying it. When I was younger, he had me listen to a song which explained the three things that comprise a country song: it has to have something about a train, momma, prison, and drinking. To this day, sometimes he quizzes me to see if I recall – and I am ashamed to say that, yet again, I forgot about prison, but! Research provides information otherwise forgot!
When it comes to Americana, I find that my brain only accepts it if it is about both temporal and spatial wanderlust, that it must address both the yearning to travel and the yearning to return, in equal measures. The dissonance between reaching back across time and reaching out across distance is, in my mind, what makes Americana.
One of the first times I recognised Americana as a genre was listening to Simon & Garfunkel with my mum. I loved the melodies, loved the instrumentation, loved the lyrics. It was, in my mind, journeying music, music one listens to as one travels across a great distance. It felt equal parts new and old, containing memories, resounding in them. Perhaps it is the song America in which my understanding of Americana originates.
Hearing First Aid Kit cover this song added layers to me that helped me redefine my earliest understanding of Americana. Two Swedish sisters, who so clearly love American music and culture, covering a song about a pair travelling across the country... if Simon & Garfunkel's version is excited with a green filter, First Aid Kit's is tinged blue, with a melancholy that makes my heart wonder if these two will ever truly experience the world they desire to, with the barriers of being from another country, of being women from another country, of another time... to know the world exists and yet be separated by a film...
I think about my own experience with America, when I hear their voices. I have never lived anywhere else; I am American by birth, to American parents. It is strange, that there are places I cannot freely go because of various aspects of my existence, which others have declared meaningful in ways to harm, terrorise, maim, kill me for. There is so much beauty to be found in this country, so many wonders to explore, so many stories to find and relish and respect and appreciate. I live here, am from here, and yet I am barred from the freedoms we are taught we collectively have. One demographic in particular fits the American mythos. The rest of us? Bones, smashed to make the walls alabaster and ivory.
Perhaps that is why I find the Söderbergs' voices emblematic of Americana – they (differently than I, sure, but with great similarity) resonate with the temporospatial yearning to be as loved by America as they love America itself. And not America the war machine. They love America the land, the promise of finding oneself by navigating the void, the possibility of being your fullest self.
The first time I heard First Aid Kit was by way of Fleet Foxes. I had recently found the latter band and was completely enthralled. YouTube found First Aid Kit for me, suggesting that I listen to their cover of Tiger Mountain Peasant Song. I, having fallen so deeply for Fleet Foxes, found myself surprised that I might like a cover more than the original – rarely was this for me the case, ever! But I found their cover had made of the original a ghost song, that there was a haunting involved which I hadn't quite detected before. It was only after their cover that I saw the story of the song unfolding in my mind, the transmutation of the self into something unrecognisable, the ghost story of surviving a former self.
That, too, to me, is a quality specific to Americana: the acknowledgement of the ghosts living therein, the haunting of the modern by those ancients and ancestors. While Fleet Foxes' version is sung in a forest at daybreak, First Aid Kit's is sung after dusk, with the closing of a round of campfire stories. It is sung with the audience hoping they are going to see the dawn.
Fleet Foxes' Tiger Mountain Peasant Song
First Aid Kit's Tiger Mountain Peasant Song
The last two albums of First Aid Kit's have seemed poppier to me in many ways, not necessarily to their detriment. Ruins is probably the last solidly Americana album they have released – and it has only one successor, Palomino, which is my least favourite of their albums. It is not a bad one! I hope you are not deterred from listening to their discography, which I highly recommend! First Aid Kit remains one of my top five favourite bands (tied for first, actually, with Fleet Foxes), and this album was not, to me, a disappointment!
To explain, I find that I am able to listen to Palomino more often than the rest. This sounds like that would be an indication that it is my favourite album, but... my metric is as follows. The more I love an album, the more it overwhelms me, and the less frequently I can listen to it. This is the opposite case with books, interestingly enough, and I believe this difference stems from the experience – I venture into a book and experience it externally, but music is poured into me and circulates through every system simultaneously. Perhaps once a quarter, I can listen to First Aid Kit's entire discography, all the way through. I can listen to Palomino at least twice before it yields the effect of the rest of their albums.
Anyway. I internally quote so many of their lyrics every single day. So many of their songs help me get through even the toughest of times. Some of their songs have helped me understand how I needed to write relationship dynamics between characters. Listen to First Aid Kit!